Tuesday, 30 September 2008
Farewell Circles and the Management of Risk
And yet I couldn't help but feel that the Farewell Circle would be an unlikely part of programs in Australia, or at the very least it would not involve the staff, because one of the ways we have responded to abuse of young people in Australia (and in many other places I am sure) has been to make it socially unacceptable for adults, particularly males, to hug children. The intention of this is, of course, to protect our children and this is a sensible and reasonable thing for a society to do. But I wonder if the solution causes other problems for young people.
I believe there are similar dynamics at play in other areas of society and not just in Australia of course. In an attempt to protect our children against injury we increasingly focus on the elimination of risk. Maybe, despite the evidence about the dangers of a sedentary lifestyle, this leads us to prefer our children watch television or play computer games in the lounge room where we can keep them 'safe' rather than be out riding bikes or climbing trees in what we perceive to be the dangerous outdoors.
But at what cost to their healthy development into adulthood, to their levels of resilience and to their long term physical and mental health?
Next time you see an advertisement for household disinfectant look closely at what they are really saying - and they are mostly not being too subtle about it either - germs are bad, if you really love your family then you will use our product in copiuos quantities to kill all the germs in your house.
But apart from this being a fruitless exercise, what impact is this having on our immune systems? On the environment? Is it coincidental that the more sterile our lives become the more we see allergies emerge?
I don't think there are simplistic answers to any of these questions. I am not advocating that we all just start hugging each other again, or that we let our kids run wild, or that we stop cleaning our houses. I believe it was simplistic solutions that got us into this mess. I think it went something like this:
1. Our children are at risk.
2. Hands up all those people who don't want to protect our kids.
3. Good, so everyone (except bad people who don't care about our kids) wants us to take all measures to protect kids.
I don't have the answers but I am troubled by many of the 'solutions' we have now and I think we need to keep examining these things in an effort to come up with better ways. I am convinced that these are not simple problems with simple answers. If they were then they would have been solved a long time ago and clearly they have not been. Logically this must mean they are in fact, like most issues, complex and nuanced - shades of grey rather than black and white.
But I am confident that if we continue to talk together and to look for better solutions then we will eventually find them.
Tuesday, 24 June 2008
A good walk spoiled?
The photo you see to the right is from the walking track around the Barwon River at Geelong in Victoria. It is the walk my wife and I use on a regular basis. It is a great walk because it is close to home and there are a number of circuit options from the car park which range from about 50 minutes up to 4-5 hours (we haven't done the long walk yet). My wife was born and grew up near this river using this track and she tells me the walking/bike track you can see has been there as long as she can remember (I'm too smart to put a number of years here!).
Then this sign appeared sometime during the past 12 months. At first I just ignored it but the more we walked past it the more annoyed I became. What does it mean? Nothing has changed on the track so why now? I have come to the conclusion that this is what happens when you let lawyers get involved in matters that belong in the realm of common sense.
I would have loved to have been a fly on the wall at the meeting to discuss the erection of this sign! How do you think it went? I can't imagine the bizarre justifications that were used at that meeting but I believe it boils down to one thing - a ridiculous and totally over the top aversion to risk and an abrogation of personal responsibilty. The gradient referred to in the sign is not a particularly steep one and if we take this sign to its logical conclusion does that mean that there will need to be a sign notifying us of every change in gradient on the track? If so then there will be an awful lot of signs. It is really just visual pollution and shows us that it is not just our children who are being wrapped in cotton wool but that our whole society which is heading this way - unless we start to do something about it and reclaim the place of risk and personal responsibility as desirable concepts.
Wednesday, 11 June 2008
Resilience - are we helping?
When Preston B. Cline was here in Australia last year he also said that in these times of rapid technological change we need to build resilience in our children if they are to cope with the rapid pace of change.
Increasingly we are hearing from commentators and academics that we are 'cotton woolling' our children in our attempts to protect them from risk. Our society is becoming increasingly risk averse - and yet it is our contention in the camps and outdoors sector that by supporting and encouraging children to engage with risk in a thoughtful and planned way that we can in fact build their resilience.
We continue to hear about the 'obesity epidemic', increasing rates of suicide amongst teenagers and increasing incidences of mental illness and depression. Surely we can't solve these problems by withdrawing further into our protective cocoons? That might be a natural reaction but it must be detrimental in the long term because it suggests that it is safer at home on the couch than it is to be out riding your bike, safer in a tightly controlled environment than it is exploring and playing. Well it might be safer in the immediate short term - but what about the longer term impacts on our health and wellbeing? To believe that we can, or need to, somehow protect our children from the disappointments that inevitably are a part of growing up and working out how they fit in the world is, while understandable, not helpful in the long run.
So is trying to manage risk out of existence, in an effort to protect our children and ourselves from harm, actually counterproductive? I suggest the answer is yes.
